The researcher helping the north weather change

Associate Professor Connar McShane.

Living through a cyclone can make you underestimate the next one.

Asking farmers to protect the Great Barrier Reef can make them feel blamed.

And offering a miner a new job won’t work if mining is part of their core identity.

All three findings come from the research of Associate Professor Connar McShane, JCU psychological scientist who studies how people in Northern Australia perceive and respond – or don’t respond – to threats to themselves and their communities.

“People often say that I spread myself thinly across all these different areas,” she says.

"But for me, they're very much related.

"It's those same frameworks that come up: that connection and identity with place, and how people think about and act on risk.

"That's my jam. That's where I like to be."

From the family farm to the psychology of place

McShane has first-hand experience of ties to place. She grew up on a sugarcane and horticulture farm on the Burdekin River, about 100 kilometres inland from Ayr.

"I loved growing up on the farm and I really enjoyed farming," she says. "But it's sort of a generational thing – farmers always encourage their children to go off and get other options."

McShane chose to study psychology because she wanted to uncover why people think and behave the way they do.

"No two people are the same," she says. "If you want to understand something, you still need to talk to or get information from that person."

For her honours and PhD research, McShane turned back to her roots, examining the impact of the working environment on the stress, coping and resilience of farming families, who often work and live in the same physical space and whose work colleagues are also family.

For these families, farming wasn’t just a job – it was family, place and identity. If they weren’t farmers, who were they?

When McShane finished her PhD in 2012, hardly anyone was working in the blended space she inhabits: investigating psychological and social factors that weren’t to do with mental health, applied to environmental situations.  She partnered with researchers in agriculture, biosecurity and extreme weather, who had solutions but needed to understand whether people would adopt them.

"Because there weren't a lot of people like me really crossing those disciplinary boundaries at that point, I was pulled into a lot of different projects," McShane says. "And I've just kept those relationships going over time."

Associate Professor Connar McShane on the farm. Credit: Lorelle McShane.

Why people underestimate their cyclone risk

One of the longest of those relationships is with JCU’s Cyclone Testing Station, with which McShane began working more than a decade ago.

Station engineers knew how to make houses stand up to severe winds. What they didn’t know was why homeowners weren't making the suggested upgrades.

"Fundamentally, humans are not 100 per cent logical thinkers all the time," McShane says. "It works on automatic processes a lot, which are fed by emotions – there can be a whole bunch of different reasons why people aren’t adopting your logical recommendations.”

In partnership with the Cyclone Testing Station and Suncorp, her team set out to understand what drives North Queenslanders to prepare for cyclones. One of the most important findings came from her former PhD student, Dr Mitchell Scovell, who studied people’s experiences of Cyclone Yasi, a Category 5 cyclone that hit in 2011.

A cyclone’s category is based on the strongest winds near its centre. Many people who lived through Yasi were hundreds of kilometres from the centre, and experienced much weaker winds.

But having survived what they believed was a major storm, they underestimate the damage a Category 4 or 5 cyclone could do.

McShane’s team and the station are now working on more localised wind-speed information to give people a truer picture of their individual experience.

"If people can say, 'Yes, there was a Category 5 cyclone, but I only experienced Category 2 winds where I was,' then they've got a better anchor point to understand their actual experience, which shapes their willingness to prepare for the next one," McShane says.

Navigating community transitions

The need to frame risk and challenges to garner audience response is something McShane has also seen in work with farmers on environmental protection.

In a water-quality project, McShane found that talk of downstream and Great Barrier Reef impacts put farmers on the defensive.

"It's not that they don't care about it – it's that they feel like they're being made the scapegoat for everything," she says.

“If you change the way you’re talking about it to align with what’s important to them – protecting the river where their kids swim or when to apply fertiliser so it doesn’t wash off in the rain – it’s then about outcomes that are directly localised to them.

"Sometimes the answers are not complicated."

"When decisions are made by people who don’t understand what it’s like living here – the access to services, access to fresh and affordable food, the realities of working life – then what’s needed for communities to function well is not properly understood."

A unique regional identity

McShane says one of the challenges is that decisions about the north are often made elsewhere, by people without lived experience of life in Northern Australia.

"I do think it's an underserved region in Australia, and so I've always been very passionate about serving the region as well," she says.

“When decisions are made by people who don’t understand what it’s like living here – the access to services, access to fresh and affordable food, the realities of working life – then what’s needed for communities to function well is not properly understood.”

"Whether or not life is or isn't different here compared to other areas, it's felt to be different.

"This is who we are, and we are not the southeast. We are not down there. We are here."

Whether it’s a cyclone, a river or a mine, the challenge is the same: for McShane, preparing the north to weather change starts with understanding the people who call it home.

Partner with JCU

Research that delivers real-world impact in the Tropics and beyond.