Research and Innovation Services Ethics and Research Integrity Animal Welfare and Ethics Independent External Review of the Operations of Institutions that use Animals for Scientific Purposes
Independent External Review of the Operations of Institutions that use Animals for Scientific Purposes
- Aboriginals and Torres Strait Islanders in Marine Science
- Courses
- Future Students
- Current Students
- Research and Teaching
- Partners and Community
- About JCU
- Reputation and Experience
- Celebrating 50 Years
- Academy
- Anthropological Laboratory for Tropical Audiovisual Research (ALTAR)
- Anton Breinl Research Centre
- Agriculture Technology and Adoption Centre
- Living on Campus
- Advanced Prawn Breeding Research Hub
- Advanced Analytical Centre
- Applying to JCU
- Alumni
- AMHHEC
- JCU Aquaculture Solutions
- AusAsian Mental Health Research Group
- ARCSTA
- Area 61
- Association of Australian University Secretaries
- Australian/NZ Students
- Australian Lions Stinger Research
- Boating and Diving
- JCU-CSIRO Partnership
- Employability Edge
- Career Ready Plan
- Australian Tropical Herbarium
- Careers at JCU
- Careers and Employability
- Australian Quantum & Classical Transport Physics Group
- Centre for Tropical Bioinformatics and Molecular Biology
- CITBA
- Chancellery
- CMT
- CASE
- College of Business, Law and Governance
- College of Healthcare Sciences
- WHOCC for N&M Education and Research
- College of Medicine and Dentistry
- College of Science and Engineering
- CPHMVS
- COVID-19 Advice
- Centre for Disaster Solutions
- CSTFA
- Cyclone Testing Station
- The Centre for Disaster Studies
- Daintree Rainforest Observatory
- Diploma of Higher Education
- Discover Nature at JCU
- Research Division
- Services and Resources Division
- Education Division
- Division of Tropical Environments and Societies
- Division of Tropical Health and Medicine
- Economic Geology Research Centre
- Elite Athletes
- eResearch
- Environmental Research Complex [ERC]
- Estate
- Financial and Business Services Office
- Fletcherview
- Foundation for Australian Literary Studies
- Gender Equity Action and Research
- GetReady4Uni
- Give to JCU
- Governance
- Information for JCU Cairns Graduates
- Graduate Research School
- Graduation
- Indigenous Education and Research Centre
- Indigenous Engagement
- Indigenous Legal Needs Project
- Inherent Requirements
- IsoTropics Geochemistry Lab
- IT Services
- International Schools
- International Students
-
Research and Innovation Services
- About Research and Innovation Services
- Partner with us
- Innovate with us
- Research Grants, Tenders and Funding
- Ethics and Research Integrity
- Research Contracts
- Discover our Research and Testing Facilities
- JCU Ideas Lab
- Find an Expert
- Contact Research and Innovation Services
- FAQs and Fact Sheets
- JCU Eduquarium
- JCU Events
- JCU Global Experience
- JCU Ideas Lab
- JCU Job Ready
- JCU Motorsports
- JCU Prizes
- JCU Sport
- JCU Turtle Health Research
- Language and Culture Research Centre
- CEE
- LearnJCU
- Library
- Mabo Decision: 30 years on
- National Reconciliation Week
- MARF
- Marine Geophysics Laboratory
- New students
- Off-Campus Students
- Office of the Vice Chancellor and President
- Virtual Open Day
- Orpheus
- Outstanding Alumni
- Parents and Partners
- Pathways to university
- Planning for your future
- Placements
- Policy
- PAHL
- Publications
- Professional Experience Placement
- Queensland Research Centre for Peripheral Vascular Disease
- Rapid Assessment Unit
- RDIM
- Researcher Development Portal
- Safety and Wellbeing
- Scholarships
- Contextual Science for Tropical Coastal Ecosystems
- Staff
- State of the Tropics
- Strategic Procurement
- Student Equity and Wellbeing
- Student profiles
- SWIRLnet
- TARL
- TESS
- TREAD
- TropEco
- TQ Maths Hub
- TUDLab
- Unicare Centre and Unicampus Kids
- UAV
- VAVS Home
- Work Health and Safety
- WHOCC for Vector-borne & NTDs
- Media
- Copyright and Terms of Use
- Australian Institute of Tropical Health & Medicine
As outlined in Chapter 6 of the Australian Code for the Care and Use of Animals for Scientific Purposes (The Code), every four years James Cook University conducts an external review of its Animal Ethics Committee (AEC) and animal operations. The review is conducted by an external panel of specialist professionals with experience in conducting compliance audits, animal ethics, animal care and husbandry, animal research legislation and the Code, veterinary science and animal welfare.
In December 2020, JCU commissioned Scientific Auditing Services Pty Ltd to conduct an external review. The review included:
- A desk-top assessment of the policies, procedures, forms and records selected from the years 2017 – 2021 were provided for review by the JCU to provide an overview of the institutional program governing the care and use of animals for scientific purposes;
- Discussions with the Animal Ethics administrative team, AEC Chair and members, animal facility managers and staff, investigators to provide detail in regard to the processes involved in the Animal Ethics Framework. (2nd, 3rd and 4th of December, 2020);
- Attendance at an Animal Ethics Committee (AEC) meeting to demonstrate the process of ethical review and monitoring of projects. (3rd of December, 2020);
- An on-site inspection of JCU’s animal facilities and animals at the Townsville and Cairns campuses.
Findings
The independent external review concluded that ‘JCU has achieved a very high level of conformance with the Code’. The review panel’s conclusion was based on the review findings identified during the review, which are summarised below.
The review panel commended the University for promoting the governing principles of the Code within the institution, the continual program of improvement of the animal ethics system, the program to ensure those working with animals are competent in the procedures they undertake, the high level of commitment of the animal facility staff for the animals they care for, as well as for promoting responsible and ethical animal use for scientific purposes through its commitment to achieving a high level of compliance to the Code.
Recommendation 1
Institutions should consider making publicly available an annual report of compliance with the Code and a summary of the independent external review report.
Recommendation 2
JCU should appoint an animal care representative to the AEC.
Recommendation 3
The University should provide additional hours to the position of animal ethics officer to ensure there is sufficient allowance to include development to improve the AEC processes and support.
Recommendation 4
JCU should, for transparency record the make-up of the Executive Committee in the agenda or minutes for Ratification of Executive decisions.
Recommendation 5
JCU should provide extra resources if necessary to manage SOPs to ensure only approved SOPs are available for use by investigators and animal facilities and continue with the review of SOPs to ensure they are best practice and approved for use.
Recommendation 6
The University should ensure there is a meeting between the institution and the AEC Chair and Manager Animal Welfare and Research Ethics to discuss the operations of the AEC and it is recorded in the minutes.
Recommendation 7
The Chair should ensure all annual and final project reports are discussed in the meeting and the outcome of deliberations noted in the minutes.
Recommendation 8
JCU should include a Category C-Animal Welfare or D-Community Lay members in all inspections of animal facilities and projects or activities.
Recommendation 9
JCU should consider more serious penalties under institutional guidelines in regard to discipline that may impact the performance of the individual or group.
Recommendation 10
The University should ensure that access is provided to approved project protocols to all animal facility staff.
Recommendation 11
The AEC application should be amended to:
- Specifically request how the design of the project will meet its aims;
- Requests a description of the steps taken to consider and apply the 3Rs;
- Request details and justification for the care and management of animals that does not accord with current best practice.
Recommendation 12
Amend the animal rehoming policy to include appropriate conditions for animal transport between facilities.
Response
JCU accepts Recommendation 3 in principle, however this is unlikely to be actioned until current budgetary pressures ease, however JCU accepts the remaining recommendations and is well advanced implementing the recommended changes.